The myth: Once you obtain your black belt, you must promptly go get your hands registered as lethal weapons. Yes, some people actually believe this. Thankfully, due to the advent of the Internet, this myth has subsided. I used to have people ask me this quite frequently back in the 90’s. Nowadays, it’s much more rare. It’s also usually asked to me very quietly, right after they’ve scanned the room for witnesses to this ludicrous question. So, I’ve decided it should be addressed in this series of articles as it doesn’t want to fully die.
I used to teach most of the Hapkido classes at my Instructors studio in the late 90’s. I was in my late teens, so most of the students I taught were older than I was. While I had command and control of the class, that wasn’t always the case in conversations outside of class that weren’t directly related to Hapkido material. So when two students began talking about black belts registering their hands as lethal weapons, I just sat back and listened…and kept the laughing on the inside. The conversation went something similar to this (note the names have been changed):
Bill (a green belt at the time, about 30 years old): Hey Jimmy, did you know that, when you reach black belt, you must register your hands as lethal weapons?
Jimmy (a white belt, but claims he’s the equivalent to a 4 th degree since his dad – a supposed 9 th degree – trained him to that level at home, about 17 years old): Yeah, of course! My dad made me register on my 14 th birthday as he felt I was too dangerous for my age and was worried I’d get into a fight and kill someone. So, if I get into a fight, I may go to jail now that I’m registered. So now I have to avoid fights at all costs because of it. That was his plan.
Bill (again, a GREEN belt): That was a smart move on your dads’ part! Yeah, I remember when I had to get registered a couple years ago. Didn’t want to do it, but, it’s the law and I knew I needed to.
Jimmy: Exactly. It’s the right thing to do.
Me (thinking to myself): PLEASE take one more step out the door so I can lock up and leave before I lose any further brain cells listening to this conversation.
While I paraphrased and dramatically shortened this conversation (it lasted about 30 minutes!). This conversation actually happened and was blatantly obvious that both were lying. While I didn’t know for sure at the time that registering as a lethal weapon was bullshit, I was fairly certain it wasn’t true. I was a black belt at the time and my Instructor was a law enforcement officer. So I figured if it were true, he would know, and he would have made me register. He didn’t.
Really, any amount of research on this topic will prove this is a ridiculous myth and no one needs, or even can, register themselves or their hands as lethal weapons. So if anyone says they’ve done so, proceed to laugh in their face and call them out on their bullshit lies.
Sadly, there is anecdotal evidence that instructors have forced their black belts to register through them…for a fee, of course. Thankfully, people are wising up these days, and instructors like this are all but extinct.
What interested me in researching this topic, is how this become a myth in the first place. So why did this myth ever come about? The closest I could find involving martial arts practitioners and the law, would be occasional mentions of lawyers bringing it up in court. Noting that someone was highly trained in martial arts and should have shown better physical control in a situation or knew that they were using excessive force. With that said, I don’t know of any court case where it really had an impact. Then again, I don’t know every assault case ever held.
Another mention I’ve found regarding this myth is from boxing promoters. Stating their fighters hands are so deadly they had to be registered as lethal weapons. A clearly false statement intended to intimidate the opponent, entertain and build hype for a fight.
Now, with all of that said, if you still feel you need to get your hands registered as lethal weapons, feel free to stop by my studio and I’ll get you registered for the low, low price of only $300!
*update! I have found where this myth most likely originated. My upcoming book will have more information, but I highly recommend getting your hands on the book, “unante” by Pete Sells as a hint! Great book if you can get your hands on it…but will cost you a pretty penny to do so. Or buy my book when it comes out in 2024 😁.
Maybe it’s because black belt certificates have a registration number that people believe this. Lol. That’s my guess. No response necessary. Was just entertaining myself reading on the site.
If not true, how would an individual who is in a relationship with a black belt that is a victim of domestic abuse able to emphasize the damage their partner caused them and seek a maximum of punishment to the aggressor? I would like a reply please…
I do understand that a key factor in learning martial arts is control of one’s self but lessons learned can and have been forgotten or ignored.
I’m not sure I understand your question as it relates to the myth of black belts registering themselves as lethal weapons. I’m going to attempt to answer what I think you’re asking, but clarify for me if I don’t answer the question the way you intended.
There would be far too many variables to set the line for such a thing (registering oneself as a “lethal weapon”) . Some people obtain a black belt in a year from an instructor who just wants to promote as many black belts as possible (as long as they pay their monthly dues and testing fees!). These “black belts” are not much more adept at fighting than a random person who’s had no training. Others could take 10 years or more to receive a hard earned black belt and could be extremely adept at fighting. The skill level between these two would be miles apart. So a “registered lethal weapon” card wouldn’t accurately represent everyone equally. And therefore, not reliable.
As far as I know, whether or not someone has martial arts experience in a court case (domestic abuse, bar fight, etc.), doesn’t have much of a bearing on the case. Note that I am not a lawyer, so I could be very wrong on that. But I couldn’t find any instance where that was the case. But even if it was something that could be used in a lawsuit, a random card stating someone is a “lethal weapon”, would be the least useful item to be presented. The actual training, with who, how long, the persons behavior in and out of the studio they trained at, would all be more useful and relevant information. Also keep in mind that if some sort of physical evidence was needed, most martial arts instructors/school give out black belt or rank certificates with the students name, rank, and test date on it. Registering as a “lethal weapon” would simply be useless in every regard.
As for trying to get maxim sum out of a law suit actually being trained or not wouldn’t really matter , it’s about damage done … If trained solider breaks your nose and it cost 1000$ to fix, they pay 1000$
If someone who never fought in there life breaks your nose and it cost 1000$ to fix….they pay 1000$
Also I’ve seen a navy seal get his ass handed to him by a old redneck who just grew up fighting , so formal training doesn’t mean better then self taught or simply learned all the time … Now ill place my bet on the navy seal every time , but it’s not a 100% … Then again a lucky hit can change a un winable fight to a fast win at times.
I am a black belt (age 12), and my dojo trains us well, but we are able to get to be a black belt at around six years on average of having 40-50 minute classes up to five six times a week. In the state that I currently live in, they have us hand in a copy of our certificates, just to have them if there is an issue.
What state do you live in? The state wants you to turn in a copy of your black belt certificate? For what purpose? And to who? The state government? Association will want (and already have) a copy as its a part of their black belt registry to keep track of who they promoted and when. But I’ve never heard of a state requiring anything in regards to martial arts certifications.
Only in Guam is one required to register for a fee of 5$ for life. Can get certificates on the internet as a gift to someone in martial arts
Thank you for the comment! I need to look further into Guams decision on this. When I first came across it, it seemed it didn’t have much to do with rank. From what I understood, it’s to give prosecuters a reason to come down harder on someone that was involved in domestic abuse. But I’ll look further into it for when I re-write this draft for the book. Thank you!
I think it came from martial arts movies. ” I’d kick your ass but my hands are registered weapons” maybe Steven Seagal started it 😆
So much misinformation in the martial arts world has come from movies, tv, and theater. I believe I’ve found what might be the origins and have added much to this topic in my upcoming book. Should be out by the end of the year if all goes well!
Wow that was strange. I just wrote an really ling comment but after I clicled submit my comment didn’t appear.
Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that ofer again. Regardless,
just wanted to say excellent blog! https://odessaforum.biz.ua/
Las cintas de taekwondo no solo representan el avance en habilidad, sino también el crecimiento personal. Aprende más sobre su importancia en este artículo.
I did some research and their thing saying to register it fake but this is worth the read; In California, hands and feet are not considered deadly weapons on their own. However, you can be charged with assault with a deadly weapon if you use your hands or feet with enough force to cause great bodily injury. For example, if you kick someone with enough force to cause great bodily injury, you could be charged with assault with a deadly weapon.
copy from a verified source.
I have learn a few just right stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how so much effort you set to create one of these excellent informative site.
When I took karate back in the early 80’s, our Sensi told us once we reached black belt status we had to register our hands as lethal weapons…🤷🏽♀️
This ” Myth” is actually a real thing in Guam which is actually a territory of the United States.
So yeah, it’s a real thing…..just not in the states. But the territory of Guam.
It’s true! I and others have commented about guam and I discuss it in more length in the book. It’s a strange scenario and the law is extremely vague and rendered virtually useless from what I can tell. If anyone wants to know more about this myth or when/why guam possibly created this law, check out my new book: https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1630620661/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?ie=UTF8&dib_tag=se&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.U5d1TaTNaHexXLeDzC__zmQ1yZ-5zXmmj0QJT5ENQbE.pvBH2WzAOqSe1Qk7XGxB49bBc_lV8tQcDA8owwmTiUw&qid=1736089855&sr=8-1